Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Why Smart Financial Companies Stop Paying for Clicks

Test Gadget Preview Image

I realized something was fundamentally broken when I watched the algorithms change again.

After 25+ years in marketing across banks, consulting companies, and advertising agencies, I’ve seen every platform evolution. Each change made one thing crystal clear: traditional media channels will monetize every single step of your customer journey.

Financial services companies get hit the hardest. We’re talking about expensive keywords that can cost $100 per click. That’s just the first step in acquisition.

Most campaigns fail because they can’t optimize the backend funnels needed to turn those expensive clicks into revenue that exceeds acquisition costs.

The Real Numbers Behind Financial Services Marketing

When I advise financial services clients, the investment numbers are staggering. Depending on organization size, we’re looking at tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands in advertising spend.

But here’s what really matters: when clicks cost upwards of $100, you need perfectly optimized funnels to make the math work. Most companies don’t have them.

Meanwhile, if you build your own channels and following, you have a captive audience. It doesn’t cost you anything more to promote to them than maintaining that platform.

The difference between renting visibility and owning it becomes obvious when you run the numbers.

What Owned Media Actually Looks Like

Most people think owned media means email lists and content hubs. They’re missing the bigger picture.

Your owned media includes phone numbers, mailing addresses, and even physical branches. It makes sense to maximize each channel and invest where your prospects and clients prefer to communicate.

The goal is one cohesive strategy that incorporates all touchpoints. This increases the effectiveness of each channel individually.

When a client interacts with your branch and then visits your website, there should be consistency. No doubt that your company is well organized and communicates internally.

This is a huge miss for many companies. Get it right and you immediately differentiate yourself.

Integration Without the Massive Investment

The first thing I tell financial services clients is to create integration points. It might be challenging with legacy systems, but most modern systems have APIs that communicate with each other.

The faster you can share information about specific touchpoints, the better. Real-time is ideal, but near real-time still works for marketing campaigns and promotional offers.

You’ll have a clear picture of what clients need based on previous behaviors.

Smaller financial services companies often worry about competing with big players on technology. Credit unions, independent advisors, smaller banks think they need massive budgets for system integrations.

They’re wrong.

There are many out-of-the-box integration layers that deploy with minimal development effort. Most solutions for smaller financial institutions are now cloud-based, which means they automatically come set up for these integrations.

Why Retention Wins First

The owned media investments that 64% of brands are scaling this year focus heavily on retention before acquisition.

There’s a practical reason for this. When financial services companies transition from paid advertising to owned media, they typically see bigger wins on the retention side first.

You’re demonstrating to existing customers that you’re listening to them. Plus it’s easier to tailor content since you already have data on these individuals.

The numbers support this approach. Phone call conversions generate 10-15x more revenue than web leads, with 28% higher retention rates.

Reducing attrition means keeping individuals from moving to competitors. That’s often more valuable than acquiring new customers at $100 per click.

Measuring Success Beyond Clicks

When you build owned media channels instead of throwing money at expensive clicks, success looks different.

Tracking key metrics becomes critical. This brings us back to the integrations we discussed. You need to look at the entire relationship and all touchpoints to see where there was a positive response.

Retention metrics matter as much as acquisition metrics. Keeping existing customers demonstrates that your owned media strategy is working.

The measurement approach changes because you’re building equity instead of renting visibility.

The Implementation Reality

Building owned media doesn’t require the massive technology investments most companies fear.

Start with integration points between your existing systems. Focus on channels where your customers already communicate with you. Create consistency across digital and physical touchpoints.

The technology barriers are lower than they used to be. Cloud-based solutions come with built-in integration capabilities.

Most importantly, treat this transition like you would treat your own money. Because in financial services, that’s exactly what it is.

The companies making this transition successfully are the ones who recognize that owning their audience is more valuable than renting attention from platforms that change their algorithms every few months.