Some of your best future customers may already know who you are but they’re just not ready to make a decision. What happens between now and then could determine whether they choose you or someone else.
THIS WEEK’S RAMBLING
I think one of the biggest mistakes businesses make with marketing is assuming that someone who doesn’t become a customer today wasn’t a good prospect.
Someone visits your website, reads a few pages, maybe downloads something, and then disappears. No appointment, no application, no new business.
And from a marketing perspective, we often treat that interaction as a missed opportunity, but was it really?
Think about how people make financial decisions: Someone considering changing financial advisors isn’t necessarily going to schedule a meeting the first time they visit your website. They might be unhappy with their current advisor, concerned about retirement, or simply starting to explore what other options are available.
That doesn’t mean they’re ready to make a change.
The same thing happens with community banks and credit unions.
Someone researching mortgage rates might be six months away from purchasing a home. A business owner comparing banking relationships might be perfectly happy with their current institution today but anticipating a need for additional financing next year.
And someone exploring retirement planning services might be years away from actually retiring.
These are potentially valuable prospects, but they’re operating on their own timelines – not yours.
I think this is where a lot of marketing programs fall short.
We spend considerable time and money trying to attract people to our websites, but we don’t always give enough thought to what happens when they aren’t ready to take the next step.
We have a contact form, maybe a button to schedule an appointment, or present an invitation to call someone but that’s about it.
What happens to the person who isn’t ready for any of those things?
In many cases, absolutely nothing…They leave and we hope they remember us when the time comes.
Now I’m not suggesting that every website visitor needs to enter some elaborate automated marketing sequence or that people want to receive a constant stream of promotional emails simply because they downloaded a guide or attended a webinar, but I do think there’s an opportunity to be more intentional about maintaining relationships with people who have already demonstrated an interest in what we do.
For an advisory firm that might mean sharing useful perspectives on retirement planning, market developments, or financial decisions people commonly face.
For a community bank it might involve helping prospective business customers understand financing options, cash management, or ways to prepare for future growth.
For a credit union it could be educational content that helps prospective members make better decisions about borrowing, savings, or managing their finances.
The objective isn’t necessarily to convince someone to become a customer immediately but to become a familiar and trusted resource while they’re making their decision.
And I think there’s an important distinction between staying visible and constantly trying to sell something…If every communication is another invitation to schedule a meeting, apply for a loan, or open an account, eventually people stop paying attention.
But if you’re consistently providing something useful there’s a much better reason for them to stay connected.
Of course none of this guarantees that someone will eventually become a customer as people change their minds, circumstances change, and competitors enter the picture.
But I’d argue that a prospect who has been hearing from your organization and finding value in those interactions is in a different position than someone who visited your website once and never heard from you again.
This is especially important in financial services because trust plays such a significant role in the decision-making process.
People aren’t simply choosing a product, they’re often deciding who they want to trust with their money, their business, or their financial future and those decisions don’t always happen quickly.
Which brings me back to the original point – We spend a lot of time thinking about how to generate more leads, but maybe we should spend more time thinking about what we’re doing with the interest we’ve already generated.
Sometimes the opportunity isn’t getting another thousand people to visit your website, it’s making sure the right people have a reason to remember you when they’re finally ready to make a decision.
A FEW MORE THINGS I’M RAMBLING ABOUT
ONE THING I’M WATCHING
AI and marketing automation are making it easier for smaller organizations to maintain relationships with potential customers over longer periods of time. This can be a significant advantage for community banks, credit unions, and advisory firms that don’t have large marketing departments, but I think there’s a temptation to automate everything simply because the technology makes it possible.
Someone downloads a guide and suddenly receives seven emails over the next ten days, three text messages, and an invitation to schedule a meeting.
Technically, that’s nurturing but I’m not convinced it’s particularly effective nurturing.
The opportunity isn’t to communicate more frequently, but to communicate more meaningfully.
Technology should help us maintain relationships at a scale we couldn’t manage manually without making those relationships feel automated.
ONE THING I’D QUESTION
How many potentially valuable prospects have interacted with your organization over the past year and never heard from you again?
Think about the people who attended a webinar, downloaded an educational resource, requested information, or started an application but didn’t complete it.
Some of those people may have had no intention of becoming customers but others may simply have needed more time.
If your organization doesn’t have a thoughtful way to maintain appropriate contact with those individuals, you may be overlooking opportunities you’ve already invested money to generate.
But before launching another campaign to attract more prospects, I’d want to understand what happened to the ones we already interacted with.
ONE THING WORTH TRYING
Look at one of your existing lead-generation activities. Maybe it’s a retirement planning guide, a mortgage inquiry form, a business banking webinar, or an educational event.
Now consider what happens when someone expresses interest but doesn’t immediately become a customer.
Do they receive anything useful afterward? Is there an opportunity to stay connected? And does your organization have a way to recognize when their interest becomes more serious? If the answer is no, start with something simple.
Create a short series of genuinely useful communications that help people make an informed decision, and give them a clear opportunity to take the next step when they’re ready.
Make sure they have agreed to receive those communications and can easily opt out.
You don’t need a complicated automation platform or a dozen different campaigns to get started. You just need to recognize that someone who isn’t ready to do business today might still be worth building a relationship with.
The goal shouldn’t always be to get someone to make a decision faster but to make sure you’re part of the conversation when they’re ready to make one.
What happens to your prospects when they’re not ready to become customers?
Let’s talk about how your organization can build stronger relationships with prospective customers, stay connected throughout their decision-making process, and turn more of that interest into new business.